Join us for Jun’ichirō Tanizaki’s 1933 classic “In Praise of Shadows” on April 29!

Featured

Please join us for a discussion of Jun’ichirō Tanizaki‘s 1933 classic In Praise of Shadows. Another Look will discuss Tanizaki’s 73-page essay at 7 p.m. (PST) on Monday, April 29, at Levinthal Hall in the Stanford Humanities Center at 424 Santa Teresa Street on the Stanford campus. This is a hybrid event, so you can come in person or via zoom, but we encourage you to register either way here or on the link below.

Panelists will include Stanford Prof. Robert Pogue Harrison, author, director of Another Look, host of the radio talk show and podcast series Entitled Opinions, and a regular contributor to the New York Review of Books, and three special guests: Mark Gonnerman, who has a Stanford PhD in religious studies, has been a student of Japanese histories and cultures since he first ventured to Kyoto in the mid-1970s. Meri Mitsuyoshi is a longtime Another Look aficionado whose appreciation of Japanese aesthetics is informed by study of ritual and intergenerational cultural transmission.

Rounding out the panel: Ethen Wood, the associate director of Stanford’s Sustainable Architecture + Engineering. For eleven years, he has taught architectural design studio courses and co-taught courses on Japanese modern architecture. In addition, he has his own architectural design office in San Francisco. He grew up in San Francisco’s Zen Buddhist community in the 80’s and spent part of his childhood in a Zen Buddhist monastery in the mountains of Carmel, without electricity. “This was part of a concerted effort by the temple to stay true to the traditions and historic experiences from Japan,” he said.

“In his delightful essay on Japanese taste Junichiro Tanizaki selects for praise all things delicate and nuanced, everything softened by shadows and the patina of age, anything understated and natural – as for example the patterns of grain in old wood, the sound of rain dripping from eaves and leaves, or washing over the footing of a stone lantern in a garden, and refreshing the moss that grows about it,” writes A.C. Grayling in The Guardian. “Tanizaki’s relish in the world and its ordinary pleasures offers a sharp contrast to the functional, plastic, disposable aesthetic of modern western life.”

This isn’t the first time Another Look discusses an essay – our discussion of Virginia Woolf‘s A Room of One’s Own got worldwide attention. We hope Tanizaki’s consideration of Japanese architecture and aesthetics generates the same enthusiasm. Tanizaki (1886-1965) was nominated several times for a Nobel prize, and was on the final shortlist in the year before his death. Youtube video here discusses his life and his book.

This event is sponsored by the Stanford Division of Literatures, Cultures, and Languages and the Continuing Studies Program at Stanford, and the Stanford Humanities Center.

https://stanford.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_ZeL5ynQVQnW6JZzrvhbHFg#/registration

A full house and a lot of audience questions for Melville’s “Bartleby”!

Featured

Another Look had a full house on Monday, January 8, as we explored Herman Melville‘s 1853 classic story Bartleby, the Scrivener: A Story of Wall Street. Every seat was taken – literally, every one – with hundreds more of you at home, watching on zoom. The discussion was insightful, lively, and engaging …. and seemed to go on forever. Thank you all for your questions. We regret that we didn’t have time to answer them all.

Another Look director Robert Pogue Harrison
Tobias Wolff

Panelists included Stanford Prof. Robert Pogue Harrison, author, director of Another Look, host of the radio talk show and podcast series Entitled Opinions, and a regular contributor to the New York Review of Books, and Stanford Prof. Tobias Wolff, one of America’s leading writers and the founding director of Another Look, as well as a recipient of the National Medal of Arts. Two special guests rounded out the high-powered panel out to four: Robert’s brother Thomas Harrison, professor of European Languages and Transcultural Studies at the University of California, Los Angeles, and Katie Peterson, an award-winning poet and professor of English at UC-Davis, and a Stanford alum.. You can see them in the photo above, taken by Another Look fan and photographer David Schwartz.

Now you have a chance to see it again – or for the first time if you missed it. The video is here, and the podcast is here. It’s certainly a discussion that would merit “another look.”

What did you think? Feel free to comment on the book or the discussion. Meanwhile, we had so many questions! Here’s a few we didn’t get a chance to ask our panelists. You can reply to them in the comments section below.

Katie Peterson
Thomas Harrison
  1. Bartleby never said ‘no’, he always preferred not to. And yet nobody ever challenged him to make a more clear response. Do we learn anything by the narrator’s never choosing to challenge the equivocation?
  2. Isn’t it more illuminating to see Bartleby as existing within the narrator, as a product of the lawyer’s decision to live an easy life, as a double of the lawyer — as his unconscious. A no-saying of the unconscious that can’t be explained or penetrated. 
  3. At the same time, isn’t Bartleby a vision of the power of nihilism, a silent cousin of the “Underground Man” ten years later, created out of the same interest of Melville’s as Dostoevsky’s in the nature of meaning in a world where God is rejected.
  4. It struck me that Bartleby was in some ways like a Rorschach inkblot test – onto which the narrator projects a changing array of attempted interpretations. But for someone who seems to have made a living by writing (if as an automaton rather than a ‘creative’ writer), Bartleby is unintelligible, unreadable – provoking the narrator’s and the audience’s speculations about what he might be or mean. So in some ways, is the story about the impossibility of both interpretation itself and interpretation of the inner lives of other people? By the way, postal “dead letter” offices deal with all undeliverable mail – not just mail addressed to people who have died.
  5. I agree that with the earlier comment that Bartleby lacks generosity. I found it disconcerting that the compassion shown by the narrator to Bartleby was not in the least returned.  When the narrator seeks out Bartleby in the Tombs, Bartleby says without looking around “I know you”… and I want nothing to say to you”.  I’m curious if the panelists also think this is quite harsh.
  6. Do you believe Melville meant Bartleby to be a direct critique of Thoreau and his fellow Transcendentalists?
  7. Bartleby was written before Melville’s Moby Dick and decades before his Billy Budd. [Moby Dick was published in 1851, Bartleby in 1853, Billy Budd was unfinished at his death in 1891 – ED.] All three narratives center on a character who is a standout or outlier from the mass of humanity. That apparently was a theme that Melville could not resist, and my question is: What was Melville driving at by looking so fully at these strange people? What was his obsession about them?
  8. Fortunately we know lawyers today are much more creative, interesting and imaginative than simple copyists as in the story.  We are artists in our way. Give us some grace.
  9. any reflections on the story as a modern day allegory to quiet quitting? or more specifically, doing what is on the job description only?
  10. Do you see parallels between Bartleby’s incessant “I prefer not to” and Poe’s Raven’s “Nevermore”: neither will leave, nor will they explain…
  11. The magazine The Economist has a Bartley by weekly column under its business section each week… it’s still relevant…John in Singapore

Finally, someone sent us Melviille’s poem “Buddah”:

Swooning swim to less and less,
. Aspirant to nothingness!
Sobs of the worlds, and dole of kinds
. That dumb endurers be –
Nirvana! absorb us in your skies,
. Annul us into thee.

“It was his soul that suffered, and his soul I could not reach.” Melville’s “Bartleby, the Scrivener” on Jan. 8!

Featured

Please join us for a discussion of Herman Melville‘s classic short story Bartleby, the Scrivener: A Story of Wall Street at 7 p.m. (PST) on Monday, January 8, at Levinthal Hall in the Stanford Humanities Center at 424 Santa Teresa Street on the Stanford campus. This is a hybrid event, so you can come in person or via zoom, but we encourage you to register either way (link below). 

Panelists will include Stanford Prof. Robert Pogue Harrison, author, director of Another Look, host of the radio talk show and podcast series Entitled Opinions, and a regular contributor to the New York Review of Books, and Stanford Prof. Tobias Wolff, one of America’s leading writers and the founding director of Another Look, as well as a recipient of the National Medal of Arts. Two special guests will round out the high-powered panel out to four: Robert’s brother Thomas Harrison, professor of European Languages and Transcultural Studies at the University of California, Los Angeles, and Katie Peterson, an award-winning poet and Stanford alum. 

Melville is most famous for his masterpiece Moby Dick, but his 1853 Bartleby is a short wonder, and his protagonist’s repeated “I prefer not to” is one of the most famous lines in American literature. Novelist Sophie Hannah, writing in The Independent, called it “a flawless and ambiguous work of art.” She writes, “Bartleby, blank in character, tests the characters of others. … Bartleby is pure enigma.” 

The short story is famous and widely available – buy a copy on amazon or abebooks.com, in local libraries and in bookstores. It’s also widely available online – google for links. 

This event is sponsored by the Stanford Division of Literatures, Cultures, and Languages, the Stanford Humanities Center, and the Continuing Studies Program at Stanford.

Register here:

https://stanford.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_05TfjtlERXesr_sv69GIJA#/registration

A lively discussion for John Fante’s “Ask the Dust”

Featured

John Fante‘s 1939 novel Ask the Dust was up for discussion on September 19, at Levinthal Hall in the Stanford Humanities Center, 424 Santa Teresa Street on the Stanford campus. You can watch the video here, Or if you prefer, listen to the podcast here.

Something you may not have known about Fante: He was the son of Italian immigrants, born in 1909 (he died in 1983). Hence, Italy considers him one of its own. So we partnered with the Italian Cultural Institute of San Francisco for the event!

Poet Charles Bukowski (not Italian) said the book had a lifetime influence on his own writing, and that the works of Fante, a novelist, short story writer, and screenwriter, were “written of and from the gut and the heart.”

“One day I pulled Ask the Dust down from the library book shelf and stood for a moment, reading.  Then like a man who had found gold in a city dump, I carried the book to a table.  The beginning of that book was a wild and enormous miracle for me….Fante became my god.” 

Panelists for the event: Stanford Prof. Robert Pogue Harrison, author, director of Another Look, host of the radio talk show and podcast series Entitled Opinions, and a regular contributor to the New York Review of Books, and Stanford Prof. Tobias Wolff, one of America’s leading writers and the founding director of Another Look, as well as a recipient of the National Medal of Arts. Novelist Terry Gamble will round out the panel. Many will remember her from the Another Look discussion of Alfred Hayes‘s My Face for the World to See in 2019.

Let David Schwartz‘s photos tell the story.

Join us for John Fante’s “Ask the Dust” on September 19!

Featured

Books “written of and from the gut and the heart.”

Please join us for a discussion of John Fante‘s 1939 novel Ask the Dust on Tuesday, September 19, at Levinthal Hall in the Stanford Humanities Center at 424 Santa Teresa Street on the Stanford campus. 

Poet Charles Bukowski said the book had a lifetime influence on his own writing, and that the novelist, short story writer, and screenwriter Fante’s works were “written of and from the gut and the heart.”

After meeting Fante in 1979, Bukowski wrote: “There is much more to the story of John Fante. It is a story of terrible luck and terrible fate and of a rare and natural courage. Some day it will be told but I feel that he doesn’t want me to tell it here. But let me say that the way of his words and the way of his way are the same: strong and good and warm.”

The book was adapted into a 2006 film starring Colin Farrell and Salma Hayek.

Panelists will include Stanford Prof. Robert Pogue Harrison, author, director of Another Look, host of the radio talk show and podcast series Entitled Opinions, and a regular contributor to the New York Review of Books, and Stanford Prof. Tobias Wolff, one of America’s leading writers and the founding director of Another Look, as well as  a recipient of the National Medal of Arts. Novelist Terry Gamble will round out the panel. Many will remember her from the Another Look discussion of  Alfred Hayes‘s My Face for the World to See in 2019.

Join the Another Look mailing list here for updates.

REGISTER FOR THE EVENT HERE!
                                                                                                      *** 

Another Look is a seasonal book club that draws together Stanford’s top writers and scholars with distinguished figures from the Bay Area and beyond. The books selected are short masterpieces you may not have read before.

This event is sponsored by the Division of Literatures, Cultures, and Languages and the Continuing Studies Program at Stanford. In a special surprise, this event will be co-sponsored by the Italian Cultural Institute of San Francisco. Fante was the son of Italian immigrants, and Italy considers him one of its own.

Virginia Woolf’s “A Room of One’s Own” – a record-breaking event!

Featured

Another Look director Robert Pogue Harrison

Our April “Another Look” event was a record-breaker, with 880 people registering to attend our rich discussion of Virginia Woolf‘s 1929 A Room of One’s Own. The “hybrid” event took place at 7 p.m. (PST) on Tuesday, April 11, in Levinthal Hall, Stanford Humanities Center, 424 Santa Teresa Street on the Stanford campus – and now you can attend it virtually, via podcast or video.

The video is up on Youtube here, and you can access the podcast on the Another Look website here. 

Another Look regular David Schwartz provided the photos for the event.

According to a contemporary review in The Los Angeles Times: “If you miss this book, which is profound and subtle and gently ironic and beautifully written, you will have missed an important reading experience.” Another Look will consider the work’s legacy a century later. The Bloomsbury author’s iconic book, an extended essay, is in public domain and widely available,

Guest panelist Constance Solari

Panelists included: Stanford Prof. Robert Pogue Harrison, author, director of Another Look, host of the radio talk show and podcast series Entitled Opinions, and a regular contributor to The New York Review of Books and Stanford Prof. Tobias Wolff, one of America’s leading writers, a founding director of Another Look, and a recipient of the National Medal of Arts.

Constance Solari is a writing coach and the author of four novels, including 2012’s Sophie’s Fire: The Story of Saint Madeleine Sophie Barat. Maria Florence Massucco, is a PhD candidate in Italian Studies who specializes in the 20th century novel. You’ll remember her from our discussion of Dorothy Strachey‘s Olivia.

The Guardian called the book “a landmark in feminist thought and a rhetorical masterpiece” and rated it one of the top 100 non-fiction books of all time. Read about that here.